Aside from Halloween candy, the next best thing to have this season is Halloween cookies. You can hand them out to trick-or-treaters, share a box with neighbors, or offer them as party favors at your Halloween bash. Best of all, you can have custom Halloween cookies to enjoy during your annual scary movie binge-watching.
This time of year, you have two great options: whip up homemade spooky cookies or go for the convenience of ordering cookie gift boxes online. Whether you’re making one from scratch or ordering, here are some of the best Halloween cookie gifts I highly recommend!
Halloween Monster Cookies
For a fun and festive Halloween treat, these Halloween Monster Cookies from Sweet E’s Bake Shop are a great choice. Each cookie features an adorable monster design, including Frankenstein, pumpkins, mummies, and bats, all crafted on top of buttery shortbread. While it’s always fun to make cookies at home, getting these Halloween-designed treats from Sweet E’s is a real time-saver, especially if you’re already busy decorating your backyard and house for Halloween. They arrive beautifully packaged and ready to enjoy, so you get to focus more on the fun and less on the prep.
Vampire Denture Cookies
These Vampire Denture Cookies are spooky, delicious, and, best of all, easy to make with store-bought ingredients. All you need are chocolate chip cookies, vanilla frosting, red food coloring, mini marshmallows, and slivered almonds to bring these horror cookies to life.
To get started, bake your store-bought cookie dough until they’re golden brown, let them cool, and cut them in half. Mix a few drops of red food coloring into the frosting to create the “gums,” and spread it onto each cookie half. Line the edges of the cookies with mini marshmallows for “teeth,” and add two slivers of almonds for “fangs.”
Make the cookies large enough to incorporate a full mouth of teeth, and assemble each cookie one at a time, as the frosting tends to dry quickly. With their eerie yet playful appearance, these denture cookies are the perfect mix of spooky and sweet.
Spooky Eyed Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies
Sweet E’s Bake Shop has another winner with these Spooky Eyed Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies. These cookies are made with a double chocolate base topped with Reese’s Pieces and googly candy eyes that add a playful, eerie vibe. While you can certainly bake something similar at home, these cookies arrive freshly baked in elegant packaging and are great as gifts for peanut butter and chocolate lovers!
Witch Finger Cookies
Witch finger cookies are the ultimate creepy treat for Halloween! Start by mixing up a batch of shortbread dough and adding a few drops of green food coloring to get that eerie, witchy hue. Shape the dough into long, thin finger shapes and press a slivered almond into the top of each to create a spooky “nail.” Don’t forget to score the dough to add some knuckle lines for extra realism.
Once the cookies are baked and slightly cooled, add a bit of red cherry jam at the end to simulate a bloody severed finger. Gently lift the almond nail, add a dab of jam to the tip of the cookie, and press the almond back down to make the “blood” ooze out. These Halloween horror cookies are sure to be a hit at your gathering!
Ghost BOO! Cookies
For something traditional, classic, yet cute, Sweet E’s Ghost BOO! Cookies are an excellent choice. These charming cookies feature three different ghost designs placed on top of soft, buttery shortbread. The adorable yet spooky ghosts will delight your trick-or-treaters or serve as the perfect centerpiece for your Halloween dessert table. Sweet E’s Halloween cookies delivery is available nationwide, so make sure to order as early as now to save time and avoid stress during the hectic Halloween season.
Halloween is the perfect time to get creative with your treats. While homemade cookies are always a great option, you can order online, especially if you’re short on time or just want to enjoy some expertly decorated treats without the effort. Make your Halloween as sweet and stress-free as possible with these cookie gift ideas!